#4 on the damage table · Premier League

Andy Madley

Matches this season: 47
Calls on file: 16
Correct: 5
Errors: 10
Accuracy: 33%
Damage score: 13.5

Who their errors affected

CRY Crystal Palace+1 −0 EVE Everton+1 −0 CHE Chelsea+1 −0 MCI Manchester City+1 −0 BRE Brentford+2 −2 BOU Bournemouth+1 −1 FUL Fulham+1 −1 NEW Newcastle United+1 −1 TOT Tottenham Hotspur+1 −1 LIV Liverpool+0 −1 ARS Arsenal+0 −1 SUN Sunderland+0 −1 MUN Manchester United+0 −1

One error can help one club and hurt another. Small samples are not evidence of bias.

Call sheet

RefereeCorrectPenalty not awarded: handball appeal against Strand Larsen
RefereeErrorJoachim Andersen red card after VAR review
RefereeErrorRyan Christie red card after VAR review
RefereeErrorLiverpool penalty overturned by VAR
RefereeErrorPenalty not given for a Michael Keane challenge on Kai Havertz
RefereeErrorPenalty to Newcastle United after VAR review
VARCorrectFlorian Wirtz goal given after VAR review
VARCorrectHarry Wilson goal given after VAR review
RefereeErrorNo penalty for a foul on Archie Gray
RefereeErrorRomero escapes red for a wild swipe at Thiago
RefereeErrorNo penalty for a challenge on Anthony Gordon
RefereeErrorLuke O'Nien red card after VAR review
VARErrorCollins only booked for pulling back Mbeumo
VARCorrectPenalty not given for a foul on Oscar Bobb
VARCorrectBrennan Johnson goal given after VAR review
VARDebatableGordon winner survives three checks: ball out, foul, offside

2026–27 appointments

MW4	12 Sept	Aston Villa 1–2 Nottingham Forest	Referee
MW2	30 Aug	Manchester United 5–2 Ipswich Town	Fourth official
MW2	28 Aug	Crystal Palace 1–4 Manchester City	Referee
MW1	22 Aug	Ipswich Town 2–1 Sunderland	Fourth official
MW38	24 May	Manchester City 1–2 Aston Villa	Referee
MW37	19 May	Chelsea 2–1 Tottenham Hotspur	Fourth official
MW37	15 May	Aston Villa 4–2 Liverpool	Fourth official
MW36	9 May	Fulham 0–1 Bournemouth	Referee
MW35	4 May	Everton 3–3 Manchester City	Fourth official
MW35	2 May	Brentford 3–0 West Ham United	Fourth official
MW34	25 Apr	Liverpool 3–1 Crystal Palace	Referee
MW33	22 Apr	Burnley 0–1 Manchester City	Referee
MW33	19 Apr	Everton 1–2 Liverpool	Fourth official
MW32	12 Apr	Crystal Palace 2–1 Newcastle United	Referee
MW32	11 Apr	Brentford 2–2 Everton	Fourth official
MW31	22 Mar	Newcastle United 1–2 Sunderland	Fourth official
MW30	15 Mar	Nottingham Forest 0–0 Fulham	Fourth official
MW30	14 Mar	Arsenal 2–0 Everton	Referee
MW29	5 Mar	Tottenham Hotspur 1–3 Crystal Palace	Referee
MW28	1 Mar	Brighton & Hove Albion 2–1 Nottingham Forest	Referee
MW26	11 Feb	Nottingham Forest 0–0 Wolverhampton Wanderers	Fourth official
MW26	10 Feb	Everton 1–2 Bournemouth	Referee
MW25	7 Feb	Newcastle United 2–3 Brentford	Referee
MW24	1 Feb	Tottenham Hotspur 2–2 Manchester City	Fourth official
MW22	17 Jan	Liverpool 1–1 Burnley	Referee
MW21	7 Jan	Crystal Palace 0–0 Aston Villa	Referee
MW20	4 Jan	Fulham 2–2 Liverpool	VAR
MW19	1 Jan	Brentford 0–0 Tottenham Hotspur	Referee
MW18	27 Dec	Nottingham Forest 1–2 Manchester City	VAR
MW17	20 Dec	Newcastle United 2–2 Chelsea	Referee
MW16	14 Dec	Nottingham Forest 3–0 Tottenham Hotspur	VAR
MW15	6 Dec	Manchester City 3–0 Sunderland	Referee
MW14	3 Dec	Brighton & Hove Albion 3–4 Aston Villa	Referee
MW13	30 Nov	Crystal Palace 1–2 Manchester United	Fourth official
MW13	29 Nov	Tottenham Hotspur 1–2 Fulham	VAR
MW12	22 Nov	Liverpool 0–3 Nottingham Forest	Referee
MW11	8 Nov	Everton 2–0 Fulham	Referee
MW10	1 Nov	Fulham 3–0 Wolverhampton Wanderers	VAR
MW9	26 Oct	Arsenal 1–0 Crystal Palace	Fourth official
MW9	25 Oct	Chelsea 1–2 Sunderland	Referee
MW8	20 Oct	West Ham United 0–2 Brentford	Referee
MW7	5 Oct	Brentford 0–1 Manchester City	Fourth official
MW6	28 Sept	Aston Villa 3–1 Fulham	Referee
MW6	27 Sept	Brentford 3–1 Manchester United	VAR
MW4	13 Sept	Arsenal 3–0 Nottingham Forest	VAR
MW2	23 Aug	Manchester City 0–2 Tottenham Hotspur	VAR
MW1	17 Aug	Nottingham Forest 3–1 Brentford	VAR