2026–27 · matchweek 4 tracked

Every VAR call.
On the record.

The open ledger of Premier League refereeing decisions. See who got it wrong, who benefited, and how every official really rates, backed by the KMI panel's own rulings.

Case of the weekMUN0–1MCIHaaland derby winner stands despite Enzo Fernández offsideRefereeMichael OliverVARMatt DonohueAssistant VARBlake AntrobusError · admitted by referees’ body
85%Right on the pitch93% after VAR · KMI panel
Most damaging officialSam Barrott11 errors · 0 match-deciding · helped NFO, CRY, EVE, CHE, ARS, FUL, NEW, BUR, MUN17damage
Matches tracked419
Key decisions245
Officially admitted errors75
Match-deciding errors4
Case file · this weekErrorAdmitted by referees’ body
Meltdown
MUNManchester United
0 – 1
Sun, 13 Sept 2026
MCIManchester City

Haaland derby winner stands despite Enzo Fernández offside

Erling Haaland tapped in Joško Gvardiol's deflected cross at the far post. The assistant flagged, but after a long check VAR Matt Donohue overturned it, judging that Enzo Fernández, who was in an offside position in front of goal and lunged at the cross, had not affected Lisandro Martínez. It was the only goal of the game, scored by ten-man City at Old Trafford. Pro Ref admitted the error the same day.

  1. 60'On the pitch: No goal: offside flag
  2. VARVAR overturned
  3. AfterPro Ref called it an "error of judgement" and contacted Manchester United to acknowledge it.
  4. AfterVAR Matt Donohue and AVAR Blake Antrobus were stood down and are not available for Premier League duty until October at the earliest.
The leaderboard

Officials

Each official is rated only on the calls they were responsible for. Errors are weighted by impact: a match-deciding error costs 3, a minor one costs 1. The AVAR shares the VAR's verdict.

All officials →
Who benefits

Club ledger

Errors that went for and against each club across every incident on file. Green means the club gained.

All clubs →
Patterns

Who their mistakes helped

Net effect of each official's errors on each club. Green cells mean the club gained and red cells mean it lost. A pattern here is a reason to look closer, not proof of bias.

ARSAVLBHABOUBREBURCHECRYEVEFULLEELIVMCIMUNNEWNFOSUNTOTWHUWOL
Sam Barrott+2-2-1+1-1+1-1-1+1+1
Michael Salisbury+2-2+1-2-1+2-1+2-1
Stuart Attwell-1-2+1-1-2-1+1+2+1+2
Andy Madley-1+1+1+1-1+1-1-1
Craig Pawson+1-3+5+1+1+1-1-1-1+1-1-2-1
Anthony Taylor+1-1+1+1-2-2+1+1+1-1
Jarred Gillett-2+2+2-1-1-1-2+2+1
Rob Jones-1+2-1-1-1+2+2-1+2-2-1
Paul Tierney+1-1-1+1-1-1+1-1+1+1
Chris Kavanagh+1-1-1-2-2+2+3
Peter Bankes-1+1+1-1-1+1-1+1-1+1-1+1
Michael Oliver-1+1-1+2-1
Tom Bramall-1+2-2-1+1+1-1+1
Matt Donohue-1+1-1-1+1-1+2
Darren England+2-1-1+1-1
The feed

Latest incidents

All 245 incidents →
Official record · 2025-26

What the panel ruled

The Premier League's Key Match Incidents panel reviews every contentious call. These are its final 2025-26 tallies of VAR and referee errors for and against each club.

Full table →
Open source · open data

Saw a howler? Put it on the record.

Every incident is a small JSON file in a public GitHub repo. Submit one through a guided form or open a pull request. Every entry needs a source, and panel rulings update verdicts as they come in.