CorrectKMI panel ruling · 5-0 voteOffsideSignificantQuiet

Goal awarded: rutter in an onside position

BHABrighton & Hove Albion4 – 0Aston VillaAVL

Sunday, 23 August 2026 · 2026-27 · 18'

What happened

Goal awarded: Rutter in an onside position. Panel: The on-field onside decision to award the goal was supported.

On the pitch: Goal awarded
VAR: VAR confirmed
Benefited: BHA Brighton & Hove Albion
Harmed: AVL Aston Villa

Fan verdict

Was the final decision right?

One tap, then pick your club. We show how Brighton & Hove Albion fans, Aston Villa fans and everyone else answered.

Reaction

“The on-field onside decision to award the goal was supported.”
KMI panel · Match Round 1 ruling · source

Sources

Officials & their calls

RefereePeter BankesCorrectcareer on file: 8 err · 58%VARMatt DonohueCorrectcareer on file: 5 err · 69%Assistant VARCraig TaylorCorrectcareer on file: 1 err · 93%

What the fans thought

Quiet7

1 of 166 comments in the r/soccer post-match thread were angry about the officiating, mostly from Brighton & Hove Albion fans. Main gripes: red card and penalty.

“Yea Gomes and mcginn should both have been sent of missed the red and multiple yellows missed the penalty and gave every dive to villa it was insane. Kamara even lunged on a player with no whistle...” · 3 upvotes · BHA fan

Whole-match mood, not this incident alone.

Something wrong or missing?

This record is community-maintained. If there's a panel ruling, a better source or a correction, send it in.

Edit on GitHub Report a correction

What happened

Reaction

Sources

Related incidents

Awoniyi sent off for catching De Cuyper with an arm in the air

Brighton penalty for a foul on Kostoulas

Foden sent off for kicking out at Bruno Fernandes

Haaland derby winner stands despite Enzo Fernández offside