#31 on the damage table · Premier League

Paul Howard

Matches this season: 42
Calls on file: 19
Correct: 18
Errors: 1
Accuracy: 95%
Damage score: 2

Who their errors affected

MCI Manchester City+1 −0 EVE Everton+0 −1

One error can help one club and hurt another. Small samples are not evidence of bias.

Call sheet

AVARCorrectDOGSO dismissal not given: challenge by Dunk on Pedro
AVARCorrectGoal awarded: kostoulas in an onside position
VARCorrectPenalty not awarded: challenge by Thomas on Stroud
VARCorrectPenalty not awarded: challenge by Scott on Lewis
VARCorrectPenalty not awarded: challenge by Smith on Semenyo
VARCorrectGvardiol stoppage-time winner given after VAR finds him onside
AVARCorrectPenalty not awarded: handball appeal against Mazraoui
VARCorrectPenalty to Crystal Palace after VAR review
VARCorrectJoachim Andersen red card after VAR review
VARCorrectRyan Christie red card after VAR review
VARErrorNo penalty for Bernardo Silva's wrestling hold on Röhl
VARCorrectIliman Ndiaye goal ruled out by VAR
VARCorrectPenalty not given for James Tarkowski holding Wesley Fofana
VARCorrectPenalty not given for André challenge on Kevin Schade
VARCorrectPenalty not given for a challenge by Sá on João Pedro
VARCorrectPenalty to Burnley after VAR review
VARCorrectPenalty to Newcastle United after VAR review
VARCorrectBrighton & Hove Albion penalty overturned by VAR
VARCorrectWest Ham United penalty overturned by VAR

2026–27 appointments

MW3	6 Sept	Everton 2–2 Manchester United	VAR
MW3	5 Sept	Hull City 0–0 Aston Villa	Assistant VAR
MW2	30 Aug	Chelsea 4–3 Brighton & Hove Albion	Assistant VAR
MW2	29 Aug	Coventry City 0–1 Hull City	VAR
MW1	23 Aug	Manchester City 2–1 Bournemouth	VAR
MW1	22 Aug	Hull City 2–0 Manchester United	Assistant VAR
MW38	24 May	Nottingham Forest 1–1 Bournemouth	VAR
MW37	17 May	Brentford 2–2 Crystal Palace	VAR
MW37	15 May	Aston Villa 4–2 Liverpool	Assistant VAR
MW36	10 May	Nottingham Forest 1–1 Newcastle United	Assistant VAR
MW36	9 May	Fulham 0–1 Bournemouth	VAR
MW35	4 May	Everton 3–3 Manchester City	VAR
MW34	25 Apr	Fulham 1–0 Aston Villa	VAR
MW33	19 Apr	Everton 1–2 Liverpool	VAR
MW33	18 Apr	Leeds United 3–0 Wolverhampton Wanderers	Assistant VAR
MW32	12 Apr	Chelsea 0–3 Manchester City	VAR
MW31	22 Mar	Newcastle United 1–2 Sunderland	VAR
MW31	21 Mar	Everton 3–0 Chelsea	VAR
MW30	16 Mar	Brentford 2–2 Wolverhampton Wanderers	VAR
MW28	28 Feb	Leeds United 0–1 Manchester City	VAR
MW28	27 Feb	Wolverhampton Wanderers 2–0 Aston Villa	VAR
MW27	23 Feb	Everton 0–1 Manchester United	VAR
MW25	7 Feb	Wolverhampton Wanderers 1–3 Chelsea	VAR
MW22	18 Jan	Aston Villa 0–1 Everton	VAR
MW21	7 Jan	Newcastle United 4–3 Leeds United	VAR
MW20	3 Jan	Aston Villa 3–1 Nottingham Forest	VAR
MW18	27 Dec	Chelsea 1–2 Aston Villa	VAR
MW17	22 Dec	Fulham 1–0 Nottingham Forest	VAR
MW16	15 Dec	Manchester United 4–4 Bournemouth	VAR
MW15	6 Dec	Newcastle United 2–1 Burnley	VAR
MW14	3 Dec	Leeds United 3–1 Chelsea	VAR
MW14	2 Dec	Fulham 4–5 Manchester City	VAR
MW12	24 Nov	Manchester United 0–1 Everton	VAR
MW11	9 Nov	Crystal Palace 0–0 Brighton & Hove Albion	VAR
MW10	2 Nov	West Ham United 3–1 Newcastle United	VAR
MW10	1 Nov	Nottingham Forest 2–2 Manchester United	Assistant VAR
MW8	18 Oct	Sunderland 2–0 Wolverhampton Wanderers	VAR
MW7	5 Oct	Brentford 0–1 Manchester City	VAR
MW6	27 Sept	Manchester City 5–1 Burnley	VAR
MW5	20 Sept	Burnley 1–1 Nottingham Forest	VAR
MW4	13 Sept	Bournemouth 2–1 Brighton & Hove Albion	VAR
MW2	24 Aug	Crystal Palace 1–1 Nottingham Forest	Assistant VAR