James Garner escapes a second yellow card (AVL 0–1 EVE, —)

Refereeing CallErrorKMI panel ruling

Matchweek 22 · Sunday 18 January · Referee Tony Harrington · VAR Paul Howard

The KMI panel ruled that James Garner should have been shown a second yellow card. Second cautions were not reviewable by VAR in 2025-26.

Fan verdict

Was the final decision right?

One tap, then pick your club. We show how Aston Villa fans, Everton fans and everyone else answered.

Sources · 2

Vote

Loading…

CommentsSort by

Loading comments…

House rules: argue about the decision, not the person. No abuse, slurs or claims that officials are corrupt. Reported comments are hidden for review.

h/premierleaguePremier League

The front page of the Premier League. Every match thread, every big refereeing call and every fanbase, voting side by side.

–Members

–Fans voting

–Comments

User flair

Live from fan votes.

1Argue about the decision, not the person
Saying a call was wrong is fine. Calling a referee corrupt, bent or paid off is not.
2No abuse
No slurs, racism, threats or wishing harm on anyone.
3No links or spam
Links are blocked. Keep it about the football.
4One account each
Club changes are limited to once a week so fanbase numbers stay honest.