Log incident
h/premierleagueCommunities ▾
PLh/premierleagueARSh/arsenalAVLh/astonvillaBOUh/bournemouthBREh/brentfordBHAh/brightonCHEh/chelseaCOVh/coventryCRYh/crystalpalaceEVEh/evertonFULh/fulhamHULh/hullcityIPSh/ipswichLEEh/leedsLIVh/liverpoolMCIh/mancityMUNh/manutdNEWh/newcastleNFOh/nottinghamforestSUNh/sunderlandTOTh/tottenham
← h/premierleague
PLh/premierleague•u/FootyVibe••via Premier League

Luke O'Nien red card after VAR review (MCI 3–0 SUN, 90'+4')

Refereeing CallCorrectKMI panel ruling
MCIManchester City3 – 0SunderlandSUN

Matchweek 15 · Saturday 6 December · Referee Andy Madley · VAR Michael Salisbury

The card was upgraded to red after a VAR review. The decision does not appear among the errors the KMI panel logged for 2025-26, which means the panel voted it correct.

On the pitch
No red card
VAR
VAR overturned
Benefited
Manchester City
Harmed
Sunderland
r/soccer post-match threadQuiet62 of 165 comments angry about the officiatingI hate modern football, that pathetic var freeze frame making an honest attempt at the ball look far worse than it was. I hate these modern rules, it's pathetic as f***. City committed a far worse tackle in the first hal…
Fan verdict

Was the final decision right?

One tap, then pick your club. We show how Manchester City fans, Sunderland fans and everyone else answered.

Full case file →
Sources · 2
Vote
Comments
Loading…
Comments

Loading comments…

House rules: argue about the decision, not the person. No abuse, slurs or claims that officials are corrupt. Reported comments are hidden for review.