Log incident
h/premierleagueCommunities ▾
PLh/premierleagueARSh/arsenalAVLh/astonvillaBOUh/bournemouthBREh/brentfordBHAh/brightonCHEh/chelseaCOVh/coventryCRYh/crystalpalaceEVEh/evertonFULh/fulhamHULh/hullcityIPSh/ipswichLEEh/leedsLIVh/liverpoolMCIh/mancityMUNh/manutdNEWh/newcastleNFOh/nottinghamforestSUNh/sunderlandTOTh/tottenham
← h/premierleague
PLh/premierleague•u/FootyVibe••via Premier League

Sunderland penalty overturned by VAR (MUN 2–0 SUN, 45'+5')

Refereeing CallCorrectKMI panel ruling
MUNManchester United2 – 0SunderlandSUN

Matchweek 7 · Saturday 4 October · Referee Stuart Attwell · VAR Neil Davies

A penalty was given on the field but overturned after a VAR review. The decision does not appear among the errors the KMI panel logged for 2025-26, which means the panel voted it correct.

On the pitch
Penalty
VAR
VAR overturned
Benefited
Manchester United
Harmed
Sunderland
r/soccer post-match threadGrumbles287 of 347 comments angry about the officiating, mostly MUN fansI'm not defending amorim in any way, but if bruno actually scored jis penalties (and Brentford got a stonewall red), we could be on 13 pts right now, which isn't half bad
Fan verdict

Was the final decision right?

One tap, then pick your club. We show how Manchester United fans, Sunderland fans and everyone else answered.

Full case file →
Sources · 2
Vote
Comments
Loading…
Comments

Loading comments…

House rules: argue about the decision, not the person. No abuse, slurs or claims that officials are corrupt. Reported comments are hidden for review.