Log incident
h/premierleagueCommunities ▾
PLh/premierleagueARSh/arsenalAVLh/astonvillaBOUh/bournemouthBREh/brentfordBHAh/brightonCHEh/chelseaCOVh/coventryCRYh/crystalpalaceEVEh/evertonFULh/fulhamHULh/hullcityIPSh/ipswichLEEh/leedsLIVh/liverpoolMCIh/mancityMUNh/manutdNEWh/newcastleNFOh/nottinghamforestSUNh/sunderlandTOTh/tottenham
← h/premierleague
PLh/premierleague•u/FootyVibe••via Premier League

West Ham United penalty overturned by VAR (WHU 3–1 NEW, 13')

Refereeing CallCorrectKMI panel ruling
WHUWest Ham United3 – 1Newcastle UnitedNEW

Matchweek 10 · Sunday 2 November · Referee Rob Jones · VAR Paul Howard

A penalty was given on the field but overturned after a VAR review. The decision does not appear among the errors the KMI panel logged for 2025-26, which means the panel voted it correct.

On the pitch
Penalty
VAR
VAR overturned
Benefited
Newcastle United
Harmed
West Ham United
r/soccer post-match threadQuiet81 of 265 comments angry about the officiatingSpurs and Man U are better than last season. I don’t think we’re much worse, it’s just that we’ve started this season with an unusually high number of red cards and some injury issues/UCL games to balance so our results …
Fan verdict

Was the final decision right?

One tap, then pick your club. We show how West Ham United fans, Newcastle United fans and everyone else answered.

Full case file →
Sources · 2
Vote
Comments
Loading…
Comments

Loading comments…

House rules: argue about the decision, not the person. No abuse, slurs or claims that officials are corrupt. Reported comments are hidden for review.